Skip to content
Calorie GuideDairy Calories22 min read

How Many Calories Are in Butter? Higher or Lower Than Greek Yogurt?

A block of butter beside a bowl of Greek yogurt
Butter has about 717 calories per 100 grams, while nonfat Greek yogurt has about 59
Summary

Butter has about 102 calories per tablespoon and 717 per 100 grams, while nonfat Greek yogurt has about 9 and 59, twelve times fewer per gram. See baking swaps, toast spreads, sauces, fat types and how to substitute Greek yogurt for butter.

How Many Calories Are in Butter vs Greek Yogurt? The Quick Answer

Butter has about 717 calories per 100 grams, about 102 calories per tablespoon (14.2 grams), about 34 per teaspoon and about 810 for a standard 113 gram stick. Plain nonfat Greek yogurt has about 59 calories per 100 grams, about 9 calories per tablespoon (15 grams) and about 130 per cup (245 grams). Whole milk Greek yogurt has about 97 calories per 100 grams, about 15 per tablespoon and about 238 per cup. So per gram, butter has about 12 times the calories of nonfat Greek yogurt, and about 7.4 times the calories of the full-fat version. A tablespoon of butter has the calories of about 11 tablespoons of nonfat Greek yogurt, or nearly 7 tablespoons of whole milk Greek yogurt.

The two foods come from the same source, milk, but they are at opposite ends of the dairy range. Butter is churned cream, about 80 to 82 percent fat, with only about 16 percent water and almost no protein or carbohydrate. Greek yogurt is strained fermented milk, mostly water and protein: nonfat Greek yogurt is about 82 percent water, 10 percent protein, 3.6 percent carbohydrate and under 0.5 percent fat. Because fat has 9 calories per gram and protein and carbohydrate only 4, the fat in butter makes it one of the most calorie dense foods in the kitchen, while Greek yogurt is a lean, high protein food.

That makes Greek yogurt a popular substitute for butter, sour cream and mayonnaise in healthier cooking and baking. This guide compares the calories and nutrition of butter and Greek yogurt per tablespoon, cup and 100 grams, in spreads, baking, sauces and mashed potatoes, explains what changes when you swap one for the other and gives practical ratios. It has three comparison tables, step-by-step swaps and an FAQ.

Butter and Greek yogurt in bowls on a kitchen counter

A tablespoon of butter has the calories of about eleven tablespoons of nonfat Greek yogurt

How Many Calories Are in Butter?

PortionWeightCaloriesFatSaturated fat
1 teaspoon4.7 g34 kcal3.8 g2.4 g
1 tablespoon14.2 g102 kcal11.5 g7.3 g
2 tablespoons (1 oz)28.4 g204 kcal23.0 g14.6 g
1/4 cup (half stick)57 g408 kcal46.0 g29.3 g
1/2 cup (1 stick)113 g810 kcal91.5 g58.3 g
1 cup (2 sticks)227 g1,627 kcal184 g117 g
1 pat5 g36 kcal4.1 g2.6 g
1 butter portion pack10 g72 kcal8.1 g5.1 g
100 g100 g717 kcal81.1 g51.4 g
250 g block250 g1,793 kcal203 g129 g

Salted and unsalted butter have the same calories. Whipped butter has fewer calories per tablespoon, around 67, because air is whipped into it, but the same per gram.

How Many Calories Are in Greek Yogurt?

Greek yogurt typePortionWeightCaloriesProteinFat
Nonfat1 tablespoon15 g9 kcal1.5 g0.1 g
Nonfat1/2 cup123 g73 kcal12.5 g0.2 g
Nonfat1 cup245 g130 kcal22.3 g0.7 g
Nonfat100 g100 g59 kcal10.2 g0.4 g
2 percent1 tablespoon15 g11 kcal1.5 g0.4 g
2 percent1 cup245 g179 kcal20.7 g4.9 g
2 percent100 g100 g73 kcal8.4 g2.0 g
Whole milk1 tablespoon15 g15 kcal1.4 g0.8 g
Whole milk1 cup245 g238 kcal22.0 g10.2 g
Whole milk100 g100 g97 kcal9.0 g5.0 g
Flavored with fruit1 container (150 g)150 g150 kcal10 g2 g

Flavored Greek yogurts can contain added sugar, with 12 to 20 grams per container, which raises calories well above the plain versions.

Butter vs Greek Yogurt: Calories Compared

AmountButterNonfat Greek yogurtWhole milk Greek yogurt
1 teaspoon (5 g)34 kcal3 kcal5 kcal
1 tablespoon (15 g)102 kcal9 kcal15 kcal
2 tablespoons (30 g)204 kcal18 kcal29 kcal
1/4 cup (about 60 g)408 kcal35 kcal58 kcal
1/2 cup (about 120 g)810 kcal71 kcal116 kcal
100 g717 kcal59 kcal97 kcal
100 calories14 g169 g103 g
1 stick (113 g)810 kcal67 kcal110 kcal

For 100 calories you can have about 14 grams of butter, roughly a tablespoon, or 169 grams of nonfat Greek yogurt, three quarters of a cup. A stick of butter has the same calories as 1.4 kilograms of nonfat Greek yogurt.

Butter vs Greek Yogurt: Nutrition Compared

Per 100 gButterNonfat Greek yogurtWhole milk Greek yogurt
Calories717 kcal59 kcal97 kcal
Fat81.1 g0.4 g5.0 g
Saturated fat51.4 g0.1 g3.2 g
Protein0.9 g10.2 g9.0 g
Carbohydrate0.1 g3.6 g4.0 g
Sugar0.1 g3.2 g3.6 g
Cholesterol215 mg5 mg13 mg
Calcium24 mg110 mg100 mg
Potassium24 mg141 mg141 mg
Vitamin A684 mcg0 mcg25 mcg
Sodium11 mg36 mg35 mg
Probioticsnonelive cultureslive cultures
Water16 g82 g78 g
Per 100 caloriesButterNonfat Greek yogurt
Weight14 g169 g
Protein0.1 g17.3 g
Calcium3 mg186 mg
Fat11.3 g0.7 g

Per 100 calories, Greek yogurt provides about 17 grams of protein and nearly 190 milligrams of calcium, while butter provides virtually none. Butter has more vitamin A, but in the amounts normally used the difference is slight. On a purely nutritional basis, Greek yogurt is the more nutrient dense food, while butter is an ingredient valued for taste, texture and cooking performance.

A stick of butter next to a bowl of nonfat Greek yogurt

One stick of butter has the calories of about 1.4 kilograms of nonfat Greek yogurt

Can You Substitute Greek Yogurt for Butter?

In many recipes you can, but not always in a one-to-one ratio, and results differ. Butter provides fat, which tenderizes baked goods, helps them brown, carries flavor and aerates when creamed with sugar. Greek yogurt contributes moisture, protein and acidity, giving baked goods a denser, moister crumb, and the lack of fat can make them tougher or rubbery if overmixed. A reliable approach is to replace half of the butter with an equal amount of Greek yogurt in muffins, quick breads, pancakes and cakes. For brownies and cookies, replacing a quarter to a half works. For pastry, pie crust and shortbread, where solid fat is essential, yogurt is not a good substitute.

Recipe useSwapResultCalories saved (per 1/2 cup butter)
Muffins, quick breadsReplace half of butter with Greek yogurtMoist, tenderAbout 390 kcal
CakesReplace halfMoist, slightly denserAbout 390 kcal
Pancakes, wafflesReplace all butter in batterSoft, less crisp edgesAbout 740 kcal
BrowniesReplace a third to a halfFudgier, less richAbout 260 to 390 kcal
CookiesReplace a quarterSofter, cakierAbout 190 kcal
Mashed potatoesReplace all butter with yogurtTangy, creamyAbout 740 kcal
Toast spreadGreek yogurt with herbs instead of butterFresh, tangyAbout 90 kcal per tbsp
FrostingReplace half the butterLighter, tangyAbout 390 kcal
Pie crust, shortbreadNot recommendedToughNone

When you substitute, bake at the same temperature, check doneness a few minutes earlier, and add a pinch of baking soda to balance the acidity if you use a lot of yogurt.

How Many Calories Do You Save by Swapping Butter for Greek Yogurt?

The savings depend on the amounts. A recipe for 12 muffins calls for 1/2 cup of butter, 810 calories, which is 68 calories per muffin from butter. Replacing half with nonfat Greek yogurt reduces the butter to 405 calories and adds 36 calories of yogurt, saving about 370 calories in the batch, or 31 calories per muffin. For mashed potatoes with 4 tablespoons of butter for 4 servings, 408 calories, using 4 tablespoons of nonfat yogurt, 36 calories, saves 372 calories, or 93 calories per serving. On toast, a teaspoon of butter, 34 calories, replaced by a teaspoon of Greek yogurt, 3 calories, saves 31 calories each slice.

DishWith butterWith Greek yogurtSaved per serving
Mashed potatoes, 4 tbsp for 4408 kcal total36 kcal total93 kcal
Muffins, 12, half swap810 kcal total438 kcal total31 kcal
Pancakes, 12, all butter405 kcal total36 kcal total31 kcal
Baked potato topping, 1 tbsp102 kcal9 kcal93 kcal
Toast, 1 tsp34 kcal3 kcal31 kcal
Corn on the cob, 1 tsp34 kcal3 kcal31 kcal

What Are the Differences in Taste and Texture?

Butter is rich, creamy, a little sweet and unmistakably dairy, and it melts at body temperature, giving a coating mouthfeel. It browns into nutty beurre noisette and forms flaky layers in pastry. Greek yogurt is tangy, thick and cool, and it brings freshness rather than richness. On hot foods it can curdle if boiled, so it should be added at the end of cooking, off the heat, or stabilized with a spoonful of flour or cornstarch. As a spread, it works on bagels, toast with herbs and baked potatoes, but it is not a good substitute for sautéing, frying or browning. For these tasks, use a small amount of oil or butter, or substitute broth.

Is Butter or Greek Yogurt Better for Heart Health?

Butter is high in saturated fat, with about 7 grams per tablespoon, a third of the recommended daily maximum of about 20 grams on a 2,000 calorie diet. High intake of saturated fat raises LDL cholesterol in many people, and dietary guidelines recommend limiting it to under 10 percent of calories. Moderate butter use, such as a teaspoon on toast, is not a problem for most healthy people, but it adds up quickly. Greek yogurt, especially nonfat and low fat, contains very little saturated fat, plus calcium, protein, potassium and probiotics, and fermented dairy such as yogurt has been linked in observational studies to a lower risk of type 2 diabetes and neutral to beneficial effects on cardiovascular health. Replacing butter with Greek yogurt, or with olive oil in cooking, is consistent with advice to swap saturated fat for unsaturated fat.

Is Greek Yogurt Better for Weight Loss?

Yes, in most cases. Greek yogurt provides about 17 grams of protein per 100 calories, which increases fullness, compared with butter, which gives almost none. Swapping butter for yogurt in cooking reduces energy density, so you can eat the same volume of food with fewer calories. As a snack, a cup of nonfat plain Greek yogurt at 130 calories with berries is a satisfying, protein-rich option. However, butter in small amounts, such as a teaspoon on vegetables, can make healthy food more enjoyable and help you absorb fat-soluble vitamins, so it need not be eliminated. The key is the quantity: a teaspoon is 34 calories, while a thick slather is 100 or more.

Toast with Greek yogurt and herbs next to buttered toast

Greek yogurt with herbs can replace butter on toast, saving about 30 calories per teaspoon

How Many Calories Are in Foods Made With Butter and Greek Yogurt?

FoodServingCaloriesNotes
Buttered toast1 slice105 kcal1 tsp butter, 71 for bread
Toast with Greek yogurt1 slice75 kcal1 tsp yogurt
Baked potato with butter1 medium263 kcal1 tbsp
Baked potato with Greek yogurt1 medium170 kcal1 tbsp
Butter on corn1 ear135 kcal1 tsp
Garlic butter sauce2 tbsp210 kcalButter, garlic
Greek yogurt garlic sauce2 tbsp20 kcalYogurt, garlic, lemon
Butter cookies1 cookie95 kcalShortbread
Greek yogurt parfait1 cup190 kcalBerries, granola
Butter chicken1 cup380 kcalCream, butter
Tzatziki1/4 cup45 kcalCucumber, olive oil

How to Choose and Store Butter and Greek Yogurt

For butter, check the label for the fat content, which is at least 80 percent in most countries, and choose unsalted for cooking so you can control the salt. Store butter wrapped in the refrigerator for up to three months, or freeze for up to nine months, and keep a small amount in a covered dish at room temperature for a few days if you need it soft. For Greek yogurt, choose plain with no added sugar, with live cultures mentioned on the label, and protein of at least 9 grams per 100 grams. Keep it in the refrigerator and use it by the date on the pack, within about a week of opening. Stir in any liquid that separates on top, which is whey and is harmless.

Plain Greek yogurt in a jar next to a stick of butter

Choose plain Greek yogurt with live cultures and no added sugar

How to Count Butter and Greek Yogurt Calories Accurately

Measure butter by weight on a scale, 7.2 calories per gram, or by tablespoon markings on the wrapper, 102 per tablespoon. Do not count a heaped knife as one teaspoon: a generous spread is often 10 grams, 72 calories. For Greek yogurt, use the label for the type: about 0.6 calories per gram for nonfat, 0.73 for 2 percent and 0.97 for whole. Check fruit and flavored versions, because the sugar changes the numbers. In a recipe, add up all the butter and yogurt calories, then divide by the number of servings.

What Are the Different Types of Butter and How Do Their Calories Compare?

Not all butter products are the same, but the calories per gram are close for the standard ones. Regular butter is about 80 to 82 percent fat. European-style butter has 82 to 86 percent fat, making it slightly richer, at about 740 calories per 100 grams. Ghee, clarified butter with the water and milk solids removed, is nearly 100 percent fat, with about 112 calories per tablespoon. Whipped butter is about a third air, so a tablespoon has about 67 calories. Light butter blends and reduced fat spreads can have 40 to 70 calories per tablespoon, while margarine is similar to butter at about 100 per tablespoon unless it is a light version.

Product (1 tbsp)CaloriesFatNotes
Regular butter102 kcal11.5 g80 percent fat
European-style butter108 kcal12.2 g83 to 86 percent fat
Ghee112 kcal12.7 gPure milk fat
Whipped butter67 kcal7.5 gAir whipped
Light butter50 kcal5.5 gBlended with water
Margarine, stick101 kcal11.4 gVegetable oils
Reduced fat spread45 kcal5 gPlant based
Cream cheese50 kcal5 gFor comparison
Greek yogurt, whole15 kcal0.8 gFor comparison

How Does Greek Yogurt Compare With Other Dairy Replacements for Butter?

Greek yogurt is not the only butter replacement. Mashed avocado, applesauce, mashed banana, pumpkin puree and nut butters each work in some recipes. Applesauce, at about 8 calories per tablespoon, is excellent for moist cakes and muffins but adds sugar. Mashed avocado, at about 23 calories per tablespoon, replaces butter one-to-one in brownies and cookies with a creamy texture and healthy fats. Olive oil replaces butter at about three quarters of the amount, with similar calories but unsaturated fat. Cottage cheese blended smooth gives protein and creaminess. Greek yogurt stands out for protein and tang, and it works especially well in recipes that already contain some acid, like buttermilk pancakes or banana bread.

Butter substitute (1 tbsp)CaloriesWorks best in
Nonfat Greek yogurt9 kcalMuffins, pancakes, mash
Applesauce, unsweetened8 kcalCakes, muffins
Mashed banana14 kcalQuick breads
Pumpkin puree5 kcalMuffins, brownies
Mashed avocado23 kcalBrownies, cookies
Olive oil (3/4 tbsp)90 kcalSavory baking
Almond butter98 kcalCookies
Butter102 kcalEverything

Do Butter and Greek Yogurt Affect Cholesterol Differently?

Yes. Butter raises LDL cholesterol in many people because of its saturated fat, and the effect is larger than that of the same amount of fat from cheese or yogurt, possibly because of the structure of the food matrix. A study comparing butter, cheese and olive oil found that butter raised LDL more than cheese of the same fat content, while olive oil lowered it. Greek yogurt, particularly low fat, has little effect, and fermented dairy has been associated in cohort studies with neutral or favorable effects on cardiovascular risk. If you have high cholesterol, doctors usually suggest replacing butter with unsaturated oils or spreads and choosing low fat dairy, which fits well with swapping to yogurt.

What Are Common Mistakes When Swapping Butter for Greek Yogurt?

The first is replacing all the butter in a recipe that needs solid fat, which gives rubbery, dense results. The second is using flavored yogurt, which adds sugar and changes taste. The third is adding yogurt to a hot sauce over direct heat, which curdles it. The fourth is overmixing the batter, which toughens gluten when fat is low. The fifth is forgetting to adjust baking time and temperature, as moist batters take longer. The sixth is assuming the lighter version is a free pass: a muffin with half the butter still has 150 to 250 calories, depending on size and sugar. Tasting and adjusting, starting with a half swap, avoids most problems.

Key Takeaways: Butter vs Greek Yogurt Calories

Butter has about 717 calories per 100 grams and 102 per tablespoon, while nonfat Greek yogurt has about 59 and 9, so butter is about 12 times more calorie dense. Greek yogurt offers protein, calcium and probiotics instead of saturated fat. Replace half the butter in baked goods and all of it in mash and spreads to save hundreds of calories, and keep a teaspoon of butter for flavor where it matters.

Frequently Asked Questions

6 questions answered

How many calories are in a tablespoon of butter?

About 102.

How many calories are in a tablespoon of Greek yogurt?

About 9 for nonfat and 15 for whole milk.

Does butter have more calories than Greek yogurt?

Yes, about 12 times more per gram than nonfat Greek yogurt.

Can I replace butter with Greek yogurt in baking?

Yes, usually half of the butter, and not in pastry or shortbread.

Is Greek yogurt healthier than butter?

It has more protein and calcium and far less saturated fat.

Does Greek yogurt work as a spread?

Yes, on toast and potatoes, especially with herbs.

Related Articles

All articles